Tuna Salad Coneys Recipe Served Warm on Hoagie Buns (2024)

These Tuna Salad Coneys take a classic we all know and turn it into a hot, cheesy sandwich that is full of flavor. Make up the tuna salad ahead of time or even freeze the unheated sandwiches in foil and pull out for a quick weeknight meal.

Tuna Salad Coneys

Tuna salad is one of those classic dishes that everyone’s mom made while growing up. And everyone’s mom made theirs differently and usually without a recipe. I always thought it was magical when our mom or grandmas just put together ingredients and created amazing meals.

This Tuna Salad Coneys recipe is from 100 Years of Good Cooking, Minnesota Centennial Cookbook. This book is full of great recipes. Barbara whipped these up for lunch on a Friday during Lent and says the flavor is phenomenal.The tuna salad could easily be made ahead and kept in the fridge until you are ready to use.

Barbara made up a couple extra sandwiches for later. She even buttered the buns, filled them with tuna salad, wrapped the sandwiches individually in foil and then put them in a storage bag. She threw them into the freezer for another quick meal down the road.

Recipe FAQs

• One of our favorite kitchen tips is to hard boil extra eggs (you need 3 for this recipe) to have as snacks, use on salads or in other recipes later in the week.
• Be sure to drain the tuna before flaking it and adding to the rest of the ingredients.
• Use Miracle Whip instead of Mayo, if desired.
• Dice up dill pickles or sweet pickles to use instead of relish.
• Instead of serving in a hoagie, put the mixture in a pita instead. Heat in the same manner to melt the cheese melt.
• Swap tuna for chicken or ham.

Ingredient List

• Velveeta Cheese Melt
• Hard Boiled Eggs
• Canned Tuna
• Green pepper
• Chopped Onion
• Sweet Pickle Relish
• Mayonnaise
• Hoagie Buns
• Butter or Margarine

​How to make a tuna sandwich?

Step by Step Instructions

1. In a large bowl, mix together Velveeta, drained tuna, chopped hard boiled eggs, diced green pepper, chopped onion, relish and mayonnaise.
2. Butter the inside of the hoagie buns.
3. Fill with tuna mixture.
4. Wrap sandwiches individually with aluminum foil.
5. Bake in preheated 250 degree F oven for 30 minutes.

​What goes good on a tuna sandwich?

• Pickles
• Olives
• Cheddar Cheese
• Fried bacon
• Tomatoes
• Cucumber
• Feta Cheese
• Crisp Shredded Lettuce
• Mustard
• Swiss cheese
• Mayo or Miracle Whip

Note:This post contains affiliate links. We earn a small percentage from any purchase you make by clicking on these links.

Linking up to Weekend Potluck.